FashionVOTE by He...Who Wore it Better?

Welcome back to our weekly FashionVOTE by He - Who Wore it Better? "Colored Tights" edition. Typically He isn't a fan of colored tights, He has written about them before when peopel took colored tights to a new level and when they just looked ugly. But after these two pictures, He has a new found faith that colored tights can look good...Let's see how the ladies of "Who Wore it Better?" did this week. He breaks down the two looks...

Girl 2: Looks like a bad bad attempt of trying to be a Nasty Girl or a Motel Rocks girl, either way, trying to replicate what you see on a model or manican, doesn't always work. The hat looks silly, the boots even sillier. Obviously this looks isn't one of He's favorites, but we move on.
Girl 1: The word love comes to mind. Sweater dress, nice! Boots with a heel, and a little high sock action poking through, He loves this look more and more as the days get colder and colder. The unsuspecting purple tights, first time ever He has seen colored tights and liked them, so credit to this girl for pulling it off so well. Not sure this was a fair fight, but let's vote.
-He

Time for the ArmHE to Vote:
Vote I Agree: Girl 1
Vote I Disagree: Girl 2

Don't forget to enter the Melvita Giveway!